Y'know.

Somewhere on a forum page here, the side arguement of what's good, or not good, or something like that, of the two Star Wars Trilogy's sprung up... and as a complete aside I was interested in finding out of who has seen all six of the Star Wars movies in one day. Does that modify your opinion of the different Trilogies when you see them as one story? Or not? Which order - chronological or completed order?

Anyhoo - the stage is yours. Peace.

Part of the problem with Ep 1-3 was because we already knew what was going to happen judging by the aftermath, the other issue is that it would probably look iffy as the main charcter essencally changes. Obi-Wan by ep 4 is the closest we have to a main charcter by the time Vader has fallen and the old cast gets killed off, but he gets killed off then, leaving us in the hands of a completely different set of charcters that have little relation to the first until episode 5. While it would be dramatic and epic story telling that does what is considered tabboo, (continuing the story with a new cast) it would probably be disorientating to a new audience.

I would probably have made the battle between Luke and Palpatine more dramatic though. Not quite on the scale of Yoda and Palp, but at least dramatic enough to look like a struggle between good and evil, where evil looks like it manages to succeed again, until Vader comes full circle and throws him to his death. (Though, considering ep 3 where he was shown to be capable of immense power, levitation and such, that would probably look a bit strange. So the entire battle would have to be rewritten, probably with Vader stabbing him instead, or epic 2 on 1 battle.)

...and they gave me the wrong food too

I think the gap between trilogies would be a little jarring all at once, too.

I was home sick from work a few months ago and, not having seen the movies since Episode III came out, I decided to waste the day watching all the lightsaber fights on youtube. I feel like that Yoda vs Palpatine fight is the only really great lightsaber fight in the new trilogy. Luke vs the Emperor isn't as big a spectacle, but acting aside (Ian McDiarmid behaves like Gollum on meth) I think it's the most dramatic in all six movies. It's one of those less is more situations.

Watch it in 1080p if you don't believe me!



EDIT: Just watched the Maul & Dooku fights again. They're way better than I remembered.

I declare new poll is needed haha. The clone was should be put on there to. Both shows and the movie. Yes I have seen all in one day. But come on you put my home province up there I had to vote for that. Saskatchewan hua

yes i took the time to watch the first movie, then i asked my self what do i like about this movie. Answer Natalie Portman is hot.

Then i watched the 2nd movie and asked what did i like this movie. AnswerDam Natalie portman is hot.

next i watched the 3rd movie, agian asking my self what do i like about this movie. Answer Best part in all 3 movies. a whole bunch of jedi get mowed down at the hands of the troopers they were protecting.

after that i said what the hell ill go to the next 3.

Episode 4. what do i like about this movie. n/a

episode 5. what do i like about this movie. Boba Fett's 2 minutes of combined screen time, and luke skywalker crying.

episode 6. what do i like about this movie. corpsey

so altogether i probley like a full 30 minutes of all 6 movies.

i vividly remember this day. because afterwards i decided to play KOTOR agian.

What do i like about this game
the fact that its perfect.

I watched them overnight. Started at 9 p.m. ended at 10 a.m.

We did 4 and 5
then 1-3 (like a prolonged flashback)
then 6

What I hate is how easily Sidious takes out Saessee, Kit, and Kolar!

I've done all 6 of the remastered straight through. That was before the 2D Clone Wars was out. Haven't done it with those in one day, but in one week - one movie of season per night. Now I' have to add in the 3D movie and seasons.

I haven't done it yet. I usually do all three from one trilogy at a time.

You and I think alike DarthJak!