I'd like to see Naboo toned down a little, but I think just getting rid of Panaka's rapport would be enough.

Naboo have won two majors in NZ - the NZ National tournament in 2012 (Pilots) and HamilCon 2015 (Troopers).

I'm on the twin band wagon and making this squad tier 2. I believe it isn't good to have any tier one pure types of squads, meaning rock, paper and Scizzors. I see naboo as just that, a tier 1 pure paper. Also, I think that polls like this are good for the community. It allows us to see where we all stand and creates productive discussions on hot topics.

While annoying I believe Bastilla keeps these guys in check as she shuts down their team entirely. That being said I wish he didn't had out twin or the rapport when he was first made. I also don't really like the idea of errata-ing everything

Option not listed.

Give him Rival with Mon Mothma.

well...

Twin death shots are stupid. Full stop.

The troopers should have been named Naboo Security Guard or something like that. They did not need the extra access to trooper boosts. Bad for design considering what they already have access to without needing to be troopers.

Rival out Mon Mothma, and you may just see Plo Koon JM take her place. Those two stack by the way. Dual-Twin death shots for the troopers. Good thing it costs too much to be viable, apparently.

Ban the trooper, or kill the Twin CE on Panaka (maybe Rapport too).

http://www.bloomilk.com/Character/1371/czerka-shield-technician

+1

Here is how I think of things.

Think of SWM as a large white sheet. The more white it is the better it is, no one likes stains.

Things like Naboo Troopers are stains. (it just doesn't fit, naboo troopers should never be tier 1)
You cant get rid of the stain until you do something about it. trying to cover up the stain or folding the stain so it cant be seen does not get rid of the stain.

What do you do with a sheet that has too many stains? You toss it out and find something else.


As these discussions for errata come up (Poggle, Ysalamiri, and Troopers, probably a few others (Klat Assassin)) I think we need to think about what is going to clean up the game and what is going to clean up game play as a rule.

The, we can fix that by adding this philosophy, does not clean the stain, it hides it. Sometimes it hides it well (mouse walls for instance) sometimes it doesn't hide it well at all (Bomb expert dude). Getting rid of the stain altogether doesn't just hide it, it gets rid of the whole problem at the source.

I don't think that this is a good idea. Good intentions, but poor application. A piece like you're talking about will always have the side-effect of seriously hurting the Mandalorian faction, which has for a long time relied on Twin. We saw that after the Czerka tech came out.

Back on topic. I don't think the Naboo are that bad honestly. I personally dont mind the Death Shot Mechanic. There are ways around it in tactics. Even If you Cannot Disrupt them i dont see it as that big of an issue. Now if anything were changed to Panaka, i think having him lose Rapport, and possibly making his CE range 6 would help. Yes i know that they have access to mas, but at least that way it can be stopped by locking him in a room.