Just wondering People's opinons on which set they thought was the worst and why? It could be which ever one you thought personally was the worst. Please limit it to only WOTC ones though, i know the V-Sets are… decisive to say the least. Who knows depending on feed back i might ask which V-Set was is the worst. Remember this is all subjective and peoples personal opinons. Don't be nasty to each other. Remeber we all like this game after all

My vote goes to Knights of the Old Republic, runner up being LotF. Equal parts disappointment and bad stats. A set that has so much promise and so many utter failures. Many of the sculpts were bad, as was the selection for most of the characters.

Legacy of the Force simply had too much crap, and a few pieces that shouldn't have been made. I cannot comment on MotF due to being on hiatus during its release and never say the effects of it, but I can 100% sure say that set also has a tremendous amount of useless pieces.

Looking at my haves, the set I have the least pieces from is actually Bounty Hunters (4):

Lord Vader
Bith Black Sun Vigo
Dark Hellion Marauder on Swoop Bike
Quarren Bounty Hunter

I only have a Quarren Bounty Hunter because I got it from a bulk lot when I started playing. I would grab a Boba Bounty Hunter if he was cheaper, even if it was just for Epics, but can't really justify spending $50-60 when he's not that useful in 200 point play. Also, I do have a reprint of Princess Leia, Hoth Commander, and there are other pieces I should probably own like the Aqualish Assassin and Han Scoundrel, but it generally seems like one of the less useful sets right now.

bump, wanna see some more replies

It just didn't add a whole lot. Most of the set already had better alternatives in RS and CS.

Back then, I'd say I only saw the following from RotS regularly:

AT-RT
Obi-Wan, JM
R2, Astromech
Bodyguard Droid
Darth Tyranus (at least until the player got a Dooku)
Grievous, JH (but only the first game after a player got him)
Grievous, SC
Separatist Commandos
Boba, YM
Anakin, SA
Palpatine, SL

Palpatine was also a huge NPE for most people, since at that time there were only a few sets of minis and Palps made a large chunk of them unplayable simply by existing.

Still, most of the hate is in retrospect. Now Alliance & Empire, there was a set that got a lot of hate upon release. People don't like square-based reprints of pieces that wouldn't even be used in a sealed tourney.

I think the best are CotF, TFU, and BH

CotF gave us maybe the 2 most important pieces ever made and will be used until the end of time: Mas Amedda and the uggie.
It also gave us great sith pieces like Bane, Kun and Nihilus. It gave us a reason to play OR with Bastilla and it was the beginning of super stealth with Bacara and the republic commando crew
I love this set because it had my favorite piece: Maul CotS(sentimental reasons). Quad attack!!! Wha what!!

TFU
This set is where the most power creep happened and is also where I started to lose interest in the game. All the pushing and renew changed the game forever. moving pieces against their will changed the style of play. People stopped playing melee because of push. You couldn't base anybody with my beloved quad maul without getting pushed away. Then you added renew to most everything and they could just keep pushing you, sometimes off ledges into a pit. Enough of my personal whining about the set, here are the key amazing pieces this set entered into the fray (in no particular order):
1.Revan
2.Boba merc
3.K3PO
4.The vader apprentices
5.The lukes
6.Ozzel (will forever be used)
7.Vader Unleashed - Removal of super stealth
8.The rebel repeat blaster - this thing was cheap, had triple and could get twin with ease.
9.Felucian Warrior on Rancor

I only bought 1 booster of this and I cheery picked it by lifting each booster until I got the heaviest one and ended up with a FW on Rancor. I used it 1 time then traded it for a boba merc. $ for $ I got hosed, but I got the more versatile piece and it has been nice to have a boba for all the Vsets.

As for BH, I don't have time to jot down all the great stuff that set presented. You could play a full fringe squad when this set came out. I didn't buy a ton of BH boosters because I was disgusted and too cheap to buy $25 boosters with no smaller option. :)

The worst IMO have to be Masters of the Force and Rebel Storm. MotF didn't give us anything really. Just a bunch altered main story characters and Djerak junk. RS was a close second BUT it gave us Veers and Tarkin and a major force battery for vader in Emp Palp.

I know TL;DR but i like chatting about WotC because that is when I played the most and the game was much easier to teach and play.

I did really like Bounty Hunters, i remeber that being the inception of the " twin attack is best attack" mindset. also loved Legacy but i'm a massive fan of the Comics (dont get me wrong Legacy had Duds *cough* Morlish Veed, worst very rare in the game, biggest waste ever *cough*
I honestly never got much out of TFU i remeber pushing and lightning but thats about it.

Agreed rebels imperials was a horrible money grabbing mistake that have us reprints of three B level characters and a bunch of fodder.

The best WOTC set was easily in my opinion The Clone Wars. We got this list of power pieces:

Grievous DAC
Durge
Chameleon Droid
Commando Droid Captain

Captain Rex
Yodabuk

And let's not forget keeping in the tradition of C-level sub characters in the canon becoming power 11 pieces in the game (looking at you Lobot) Gha Nakht

Also if you include starters then there is easily the strongest pieces in any starter yet Dooku, and the much more powerful GOWK. As well as the special release bearing the clone wars set name of the lancer/Clonetrooper on speeder.

As a clone wars fan that was huge for me and as pieces that are still good today years later this set can hardly be matched.

bump

Bump i guess