|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 5/14/2008 Posts: 2,063
|
I'm short on time this week so I am sorry if I don't go the play-by-play for what I like and don't like. My vote is for Lord Ball.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/19/2010 Posts: 1,029
|
Deathwielded, Cathar Jedi: 8.75 Jedi Guardian issue aside, I'm not a fan of how Critical Strike operates.
CorranHornsux123, Troubled Jedi: 9 This version has come a long way since it's initial version, Very nice all-inclusive version.
markedman247, Corrupted Jedi Knight: 9 Pretty much an upgraded version of the official version, my only issue is the Synergy for Sith Revan, as I think it should be the other way in that case (Sith with synergy for OR Revan), though in that case Dark Temptation would probably be swapped for Sith Rage.
AndyHatton, Jedi Knight: 8.75 Cloaked + Parry make her incredibly strong defensively, I think a reduction in Defense and a slight boost in cost would make this a solid figure that wouldn't flat out replace the official version.
CerousMutor, Knight of the Old Republic: 8.75 I really like what you have going here, however I think with FR 1 lower starting with 1 or 2 force would be better, The other thing is I'm not sure what to think of your version of Force Camouflage - it's good that it not overly powerful for 1 FP, but I wonder if it's useful enough in play.
My Vote is for CorranHornsux123, overall I really like all the entries this week, a few tweaks to any entry and it would have required a dice roll to decide.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 6/4/2013 Posts: 1,093
|
Deathwielded, Cathar Jedi: 9 Jedi Guardian is a good ability maybe to good with Kira Carson
CorranHornsux123, Troubled Jedi: ME
markedman247, Corrupted Jedi Knight: 9 Liked the Affinity for Sith Revan (Even tho in KOTOR 2 Sith Revan kills her and Jolee.)
AndyHatton, Jedi Knight: 9 I agree with Lord_Ball Cloak and Parry are very deadily here
CerousMutor, Knight of the Old Republic: 9 I likes FC maybe have it cost 2? but thats just me and liked her stats and costing.
Lord_Ball's Juhani, Advocate of Light 9.25 I love the name and Dodge is a nice SA, Versatility, and Force Slow fit her well.
My vote goes for Lord_Ball this week good job everyone it was a tough decision because not many people entered and all characters were great.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 3/19/2013 Posts: 1,249
|
Deathwielded's (that's me!) Juhani, Cathar Jedi Mine. CorranHornsux123's Juhani, Troubled Jedi I think you tried too hard to make her better in the Sith, Force Link is a good idea, Observation is a interesting SA (I believe jwlynch created it) I'm not sure what I think about it... Force powers are good. 8 Lord_Ball's Juhani, Advocate of Light Versatility I believe should be reserved for characters that has several versions IMO, but I see your point and it definitely does what you want it to do. Force Slow is good work 9 markedman247's Juhani, Corrupted Jed Knight I hate to compare custom SA's but you did kinda copy LB's Force Slow and I like his better... Everything else is fine. This is a more defensive version to be sure, nothing bad about her Loner was a good choice. 8.25 AndyHatton's Juhani, Jedi Knight Low starting fp's with renewal is fitting for unique characters that weren't known for their force prowess. Lightsaber Throw 2 is a good choice for a FP and it could work nicely with Force Cloak. Intervene is an interesting SA one that could be argued is outdated because of Decoy. I would beg the differ, I like that this works better logically though I might ask if she gets cover when Cloaked does she prevent the attack or does Revan still get targeted? (perhaps with Cover bonus) I believe Revan would still be the target. Her Affinity should help replace the Jedi Crusaders, Parry is an interesting choice, but Juyo Style Mastery is what will make or break this character. It is an Epic's SA with some good effects for her, I agree that Juyo was probably her style, however I'm not a fan of how they created this SA as a stronger version of Vaapad in my mind they should've gone with a different effect. I still think she is undercosted by about 5 points, but she still gets my vote and a rating of 9.25 CerousMutor's Juhani, Knight of the Old Republic I just realized she is missing Melee Attack! Although she could be equiped with a blaster in game I didn't think anyone would represent that! Maybe it's a mistake, but it works with your version of Force Camouflage (which I wouldn't like otherwise) the only thing is I think she would need a Lightsaber SA or FP (I don't think Lightsaber Duelist counts) I like how Impulsive Sith Lightning turned out in fact if they ever created a V-set version of her I hope it will be on her! 8.5
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 3/19/2013 Posts: 1,249
|
Voting will continue for the next.... 17 hours? 4 Pm were I'm at. currently (at the time of this writing) it is 11pm, but Bloo says it's about 3 am so about a four hour time difference
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 8/27/2008 Posts: 990
|
Sorry for this one, work got in the way. I couldnt make any of the changes I neede too on her and never got a god look at everyones else to comment.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 7/29/2011 Posts: 1,766 Location: In a sinkhole on Utapau
|
You can still vote, if you haven't gotten to, it isn't too late .
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 7/29/2011 Posts: 1,766 Location: In a sinkhole on Utapau
|
My votes for this week . Now, keep in mind, I am not very familiar with the character, so these ratings will reflect less representation and more game playability/ability selection etc. And here they are!: Juhani, Cathar Jedi (Deathwielded) 9 I like this Juhani. All the custom SA's are nice, if situational. I love Camouflage, and the Revan synergies are nice. Juhani, Troubled Jedi (CorranHornsux123) 9 Observation is quite nice (maybe a little cleanup needed in the wording). As far as the character goes though, I like the 'dark side' of this piece, but I feel that while all the dark side abilities are nice by themselves, she is too strong in the Sith faction to be really worth playing much in the intended faction (OR). Not a bad build overall though, I like it! Juhani, Advocate of Light (Lord_Ball) 10 Nice use of Versatility, Dodge is a nice little bonus that helps with her defense. I love the mixture of abilities here. Force Slow is creative and nicely executed. I feel Wizards would have made it replace turn, but then, what did Wizards do that we really need to follow? . I love it. Juhani, Corrupted Jed('i') Knight (markedman247) 9 Seems a bit ability-heavy for her cost (13 the way I count them). I like your Force Slow a lot as well. Definitely some nasty damage for her cost, and plenty of survivability. I like what you did with her. Juhani, Jedi Knight (AndyHatton) 9 Juyo is NASTY on a piece this size! I don't think it's unwarranted or breaks the piece though. You MAY want to come up with a standard Juyo Style though, being as how she is a 30 point piece (Juyo Mastery has been used only on an Epic so far!). I love your Force ability selection. Juhani, Knight of the Old Republic (CerousMutor) 8 I don't know if she'll last long enough to be worth 30 in most situations, but then, she has enough damage potential that she could. I think Force 3 +Renewal 1 is a bit high, because unless she gets the Sith Lightning (which isn't always powerful enough that she'll use it), she'll just have a lot of left over Force points I think, like Master Windu...
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/19/2010 Posts: 1,029
|
pegolego wrote:Juhani, Troubled Jedi (CorranHornsux123) 9 Observation is quite nice (maybe a little cleanup needed in the wording). As far as the character goes though, I like the 'dark side' of this piece, but I feel that while all the dark side abilities are nice by themselves, she is too strong in the Sith faction to be really worth playing much in the intended faction (OR). Not a bad build overall though, I like it! Keep in mind that The Revanchist has "Unique (counts as a character whose name contains Revan)", so Force Link and Synergy are cheaper options in the OR than they are in the Sith (plus she can gain Ambush from him).
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 7/29/2011 Posts: 1,766 Location: In a sinkhole on Utapau
|
Lord_Ball wrote:pegolego wrote:Juhani, Troubled Jedi (CorranHornsux123) 9 Observation is quite nice (maybe a little cleanup needed in the wording). As far as the character goes though, I like the 'dark side' of this piece, but I feel that while all the dark side abilities are nice by themselves, she is too strong in the Sith faction to be really worth playing much in the intended faction (OR). Not a bad build overall though, I like it! Keep in mind that The Revanchist has "Unique (counts as a character whose name contains Revan)", so Force Link and Synergy are cheaper options in the OR than they are in the Sith (plus she can gain Ambush from him). True, thanks for pointing that out. I guess that in OR all she has to lose is LotDS.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Bloo Milk Member Groups: Member
Joined: 3/19/2013 Posts: 1,249
|
Here are the results for all you cat lovers out there! CerousMutor's Juhani, Knight of the Old Republic 9,8.75,9,8.5,8 for an average of 8.65 markedman247's Juhani, Corrupted Jed Knight 9,9,8.25,9 for an average of 8.8125 Deathwielded's (that's me!) Juhani, Cathar Jedi 8.75,8.75,9,9 for an average of 8.875 CorranHornsux123's Juhani, Troubled Jedi 8.75,9,8,9 for an average of 8.6875 AndyHatton's Juhani, Jedi Knight 8.75,8.75,9,9.25,9 for an average of 8.95 Lord_Ball's Juhani, Advocate of Light 9.25,9.25,9,10 for an average of 9.375 and since he is the highest rated he gets for a total of 5! Congrats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
Guest |