So after Dooku switched sides, I would have killed the remaining 3 Porgs for 15+10 for gambit for a total of 182. So the final would have been thereisnotry 199 - 182 chiech22.

if Thereisnotry had no more pieces tho, wouldn't that mean he'd lose? I would think if the opponent eliminates all opposing pieces, that the win should go to that player.

That's correct, but it's not what happened. It sounds like TINT conceded before time was up. Chiech would have finished him off or could have sat in gambit until he had the points, but the game just ended.

If time had run out in this circumstance, TINT would win because he had more points. Since that didn't happen, it's really up to the TO how to resolve it.

If a judge had been called, the players likely would have been asked to play it out. It's true that if all of one player's pieces are dead, the other will get a 3 point win. But that wasn't the case.

That's not correct; I never conceded. I thought that since none of my remaining characters (Porgs) could do damage, that the game was automatically over.

TINT did not concede.

I disregarded the timer when it went off. I didn't keep the logfile, but I was up 120-115 or something at that point. I had a 120hp Dooku and chiech had just recently killed my Assaj Ventress.

And I thought my betrayal in the first round of games was massive, lol. God, I hate that stupid ability.

gandalf over Overley28 247-175 (3-1)

Overley vetoed Fringe, Sith, Vong, Imperials and I had already played Rebels.

I vetoed Fringe, Old Republic, Vong, Imperials and he had already played Sith.

I played NR: http://www.bloomilk.com/Squad/240184/pointiest-pilots

--Pointiest Pilots--
42 Garm Bel Iblis, Ruthless Tactician
33 Luke Skywalker, New Republic Hero
32 Jaina Solo Fel, Jedi Master
29 Ganner Rhysode
23 Anakin Solo
18 Klatooinian Captain
10 Jagged Fel
8 R7 Astromech Droid
5 Porg

Preferred Reinforcements:
(Garm, RT) 19 Finn

(200pts. 10 activations)

Overley played Rebels: http://www.bloomilk.com/Squad/246037/vg---han-shot-first

--VG - Han Shot First--
48 Han Solo, Captain of the Millennium Falcon
44 Luke Skywalker, Hero of Endor
30 Chewbacca, Rebel Hero
21 Lando Calrissian, Infiltrator
18 Artoo-Detoo (R2-D2)
14 General Rieekan
14 Princess Leia, Hero of Endor (swapped from Leia RC)
6 C-3PO

(195pts. 8 activations)

I won map so we played on Mushroom Planet. Overley set up on the left.

Round 1, we both advanced, with his Luke getting to gambit. At the end of the round after outactivating I levitated Jaina in to attack Luke. She hit Luke twice for 20 damage with him failing LS Defense, and she parried all the Djem So attacks. 10-10

Round 2, we both rolled 20 for init, then Overley rolled a 20 on the reroll. Han Shot First and went after his daughter, hitting her twice. She failed both Evades, no rerolls or Porgs allowed because of HSF, and died instantly. Luke NRH ambushed Luke HOE. The first got Defensed, the second hit, and I was too scared to make the third because Djem So had already knocked my Luke down to 20HP. Ganner came to the rescue and levitated my Luke to safety. Leia moved Chewie, but he failed the save for Garm's CE and lost his turn. Artoo closed the middle door wih Override, and we did some positioning. Overley 52-20 gandalf

Round 3, Overley won init and made me go first. I spun Jag. Rebel Luke moved out of gambit onto my side of the map with Knight Speed and took out my Klat Captain, and then Leia pushed him a little further from my attackers. I levitated Anakin into the middle for a massive Unleash the Force, hitting Artoo, Han, Threepio, Chewie and Lando, with Overley failing every single save so all of them took 60 damage. Chewie and Han killed Anakin. I ran my R7 into the room to base Lando, and then used Garm's "Fire at Will" on Finn to deal 10 auto-damage to them both, killing Lando. Artoo locked the middle door with Override. Finn took a shot at Rebel Luke but got evaded. I moved NR Luke back closer to the action. Overley 103-57 gandalf

Round 4, Overley won init and Rebel Luke retaliated against Finn, but I rolled both Avoid Defeat saves so he lived with 10HP. Garm moved to put Luke in Traps, and Finn hit once for 30 with Bravado and got his other attack defensed, leaving Luke at 10HP. Overley opened the middle door with Artoo, and Chewie came in past Ganner and hit NR Luke. I rolled a 9 on the LS Defense save but forgot to use a Porg! blastedit. NR Luke dies, Ganner gets hit for 30 with Cleave. Jag finished off Rebel Luke. My R7 closes the middle door with Override. Leia moves around the top and takes a shot at Finn, but I make both Avoid Defeat saves again! Leia moves Han who makes his Garm save and Chewie who takes an AoO from Ganner leaving him at 20HP. Han takes a shot at my R7, hitting, and mobiles up to the top door. Ganner pushes Chewie to death and Rieekan moves up from the back. Overley 146-141 gandalf

Round 5, Overley won init and Han moves above the central room and finally finishes Finn, and then backs away. I can't reach him with Force Push or enough damage to kill him (especially with Evade), so I take the coward's way. My R7 locks the top door to gambit, and Ganner comes into gambit and Pushes Artoo to death. Leia missed a shot on Jag, and Rieekan moved up to join the crew. Jag ran away into the gambit room as did Garm after missing a shot at Leia. Only I got gambit. Overley 165-169 gandalf

Round 6, Overley won init and made me go first. R7 moved and kept the top door to gambit locked. Overley moved Rieekan to open the left door and used Leia to push Han 6, but Han failed the Garm save. I moved my guys in the central room, putting them all around a corner so they couldn't be shot from outside. Overley 165-179 gandalf

Round 7, Leia pushed Han again but he failed the Garm save again so was left outside for now. I spun my guys in gambit. Overley 165-189 gandalf

Round 8, Overley won init and made me go first, and my R7 kept the door locked. Leia pushed Han, with him making the save this time, and Han took a shot at the R7 but missed. Jag hit Han for 20 and Ganner finished him off with a Force Push. Rieekan tried to do some damage but at the end of the round I was over 200.

It was a very fun and close game, with some very lucky and unlucky dice rolls turning it in my favour. I felt a bit stink about playing door games at the end, but you gotta do what you gotta do when Han can take out half a squad if he shoots first.

Backtracking and playing out is the technically correct method when there was an (unintentional) illegal game state. It does not sound like there was ever an illegal game state. Am I missing something that was an illegal game state? A rule played wrong, an ability misused, etc.?

Thank you. I'm going to give my ruling soon