1. Surf
2. Swine
3. Spry

Gandalf, my poor poor droids, why so much hate? Haha. Overall good mix of abilities though!

LB, nice to see another fighter to go along with Lyn. I think you toned him down to much for his cost though, with no ranged defense and spin replacing turn to attack at +3 base and +10, he gets outclassed by everything else that's cheaper than him.

Jen, you cleared up the rules issues I had but very wordy now. Always tricky to balance theme with gameplay but nice to see another sarlaac and I like yours better than Vset version.

Alex, this is the definitive desert Obi. Great stuff! ED and the form are amazing.

CHS, Still unsure about disrupted rifle as it's one of the strongest abilities in the game, more toned down now but Fett or Cad Bane with Extra Attack is still pretty freaky. That being said heavy weapons and munitions alone are awesome abilities.

Blem, a truly worthy colossal piece that would have fit right alongside the old AT-AT of old.

Swine, pretty specific piece and great against rebels. Does seem thematically weird though that this Droid can be subject to CEs but all of the other vastly superior programmed droids can't haha.

Emperor, a bit on be wordy side but very clever designing to help out the old underutilized mercs and Casino boss is really interesting as well but could be harder to keep track of if you have multiple characters affected by it.

Surf, huge, check. Boost up Rebel Storm pieces, check. Excellent art, check as well. All systems good and another excellent surf entry. Great changes!

Shmi, very interesting piece, removing Melee Attack is super clever and creative. Also they are the original super stealth attackers so I think your CE is appropriate. Only thing I think is off is slug thrower and feel like it should go through Shields not armor. But then again armor piercing rounds rip through armor so what do I know haha.

Jak, a true monster. Good stuff here, always hard to keep the Ability count down on Huges so I'll ignore that. And I think I would have reworded SLH, also blood hunger probably isn't needed as I'm sure it would have trashed a Droid just for kicks as well and Huges already have their size as a restriction. All in all great and chomp is especially awesome.

Spry, incredible and epic Anakin, truly one that we needed and a solid example of it.

3rd Blem
2nd Alex
1st Surf

1: Surf, you made a huge piece, and it goes great with my sandcrawler!
2: Jen'ari I think you made a very interesting sarlac, that isnt too powerful, but powerful enough for what it is (and still not something to be triffled with)
3: jak : she doesnt look hungry the poor dear is hungry :( someone think of the poor hungry Rancor :(

This was a fun theme, and everyone hit it well, in a wide variety of ways.

1st - surf (Classic Jawa flavor, and that card pic! I didn't think to suggest Clan Leader over Camaraderie, but this way they get to keep their boosts, and since the barge is such a big target, seems fair.)

2nd - Spry (Anakin turned out very nicely, without overkill.)

3rd - Emperor Dragon (Casino Boss is just too fun to pass over, and the CE is cool. Great flavor all around.)


Blem and jen'ari: Iconic entries for sure. Both are complicated pieces by nature, but you represented them well. I'd like to see a CCC focused specifically on scenario pieces, maybe even all-Colossal. (sorry surf )

jak: Great character choice (I dig Rancors). Also, perfect place to reuse Chomp. I'll echo others' comments that the SLH effect seems a bit off for some reason.

CHS: Cool idea, I think he could do a bit less, and Disruptor may need some additional vetting.

Alex: Love the Forms idea, and his mix of abilities are fitting. Nice work! (very close for 3rd here)

GG: Nice representation. (also close for 3rd)

Lord Ball: Also close for 3rd, lol. Gaderffii is cool. I've never played the game, but I watched the video. (He seems better there, haha). Solid and simple design as usual. I like it!

shmi15: Handing out guns to Tusken Raiders is an interesting spin, and the Super-Stealth CE is a nice old-school touch. Spry's Anakin might have a bit of trouble slaughtering them fast enough. ;)

Gandalf: Your Chalmun is very well done, I'm just really not into more than -1 cost for Wuher.

Edited:
Think I have everyone covered now.

Not everyone has voted thoug. Technically we still have until tomorrow for the last couple of stragglers, but Surf is in a pretty commanding lead. Also Surf can't win until he votes otherwise Spry wins again as he's currently second haha.

Anyways still waiting on Emperor, Surf, Gandalf, LB and Jak. Man a lot of entries this week.

I think that would be a good call LB, he has to be able to take on Lyn. Haha. Would be sweet to see him make an appearance in SWM along with the rest of the cast of fighters (would finally give a use for Princess Leia captive sculpt hahaha). But only after we get the true missed video game heroes Rianna and Zeeo! One day. Grievous with disciplined leader, Abeloth and those two have been my most requested pieces from the start.

Thoughts ...... some incomplete ....

jak - Jabba's Pet Rancor. Costed right, but as was noted, awfully vicious compared to WOTC Rancor.


shmi - Jundland Gen. So little is said/known according to Wook. Lot of that this week. Honestly don't know if he's spot on or a mile off.


GG - Maul, Shadow Collective. I have seen the episode arc but never bothered to examine it That closely (No idea how close yours is to what he portrayed ... my bad on that.) He's got too much for a card is all thats come to me this sec ... seems like he does a lot.


EmDragon - Lady Valarian. I see that name and all I can think of is that weird sci-fi movie from last summer.Ok, I still find it hard to believe Jabba let her live long enough to be a rival of sorts. Casino Boss is very interesting.


Swine - Maul's Droids. Seems interesting, but as noted, PtO; my worry is that if Koba thinks that it can be exploited (to the bad) then I'd take his word on it; he likes his lil metal guys more than GG does ....


blem - Sandcrawler. It's just a lil too RPG for me, which isn't a knock on it as such, just in the SWM context. Always wondered exactly how big Were those things ... answer not big enough if the Empire was pissed at you in reality.


spry - Anakin/Killer. Very much the Anakin/shmi's avenger here (why didn't shmi do this one??) I guess my only gripe would be, as with Alex's Ben, is not Another Anakin/Obi-Wan.


CHS - Black Market. Disruptor is the key to this guy's raison d'être. He's at that tricky spot; interesting/dangerous and I'm not sure how I feel about that. Still not too crazy about handing out Prox. Mines .....


Alex - Old Ben. His Faction could be an issue; maybe the best bet was Republic/Rebel with an affinity for the other ... but like I said to poor spry ..."Not Another Anakin/Obi-wan."


jen - Sarlaac. I like your Sarlaac, nice job (did I make one previously, I need to look ...)


LB - KkH'Oar'Rrhr (Hoar) Another Tusken .... lots of love lately for them .....


Gandalf - Chalmun. Seems to be a Lot of Wookies on such an un-arboreal world. He seems fascinating yet incomplete ... not sure why.

Votes in a bit. I actually have to work .... what a concept .....

Lots of choices .... lots of good pieces ... lots deserving votes .... gotta keep it simple


3rd - EmpDragon. Casino Boss alone got this one a point


2nd - LB. The Tusken's continue to flesh out.


1st - Jen. I made a Sarlac six years ago. Years is more, as I just said, "Fleshed Out."


Many fascinating pieces and viewpoints all around people

Man, that makes voting so much easier! Just need to figure out the order.

NOOOOOOO .... That means we can only vote for the Fantastic Four!!! .... do we flip coins from now on ?