With Sith Alchemy X, is/are the new character(s) created from using this ability when defeated worth there point cost?

Or if I can word it better, when my opponent creates one of these do I get points for defeating the Sith Alchemy characters?

Then I am of the opinion (like that’s a news flash I’m sure) that this force powers really needs to be looked at again…and should have a save mechanic added to it…even if it’s as absurd as a save of 16…

I’m not saying the damage shouldn’t be automatic but the ability to add the Sith Alchemy creature should have the save…

I just can’t see giving my opponent a free piece after killing my piece and then earning nothing for that piece when I kill it…especially with something like a Rakghoul who can then turn around and make more creatures of its self as it kills my pieces.

Because there are a plethora of characters (468 matter fact, although I’m sure some of those are repeats when I did the search) who have 20 or less hit points and a good number of characters who, after taking 10-20 points of damage, find them self in this 20 hit point area also…

The loss of the character to this force ability is not the issue again…I can deal with losing a piece with no save…but my opponent getting a free piece afterwards that I earn nothing for needs to be reconsidered…either by adding the save mechanic or allowing one to earn points for those pieces.

No. This is covered in the glossary defination of Rakghoul Disease.

And Sith Alchemy works the way it does in order to keep it inline with Rakghoul Disease. On a practical level, they didn't want to keep track of who costs points and who doesn't, since the Raks can get a bit crazy.

there is a differnce between SithAlc and a Rak actually killing a piece off...one being a Rak has to be adjecent and has to have physically attacked the piece (if you want you can equate that to a save mechinic in itself, because it has to hit the target)...Sith Alc is ranged attack and automatically kills your piece and GIVES you opponent a free attacking piece...no rolls neccessary. No attack roll, no save mechinic, no special initiative number to roll (I mention this because Reinforcements calls for a special initiative number; oh and they count for points when defeated), just a free piece for spending 1-2 force points...

again I want to be clear, the automatic damage is NOT my concern...it is the AUTOMATIC free piece for my opponent that I earn no points for. There are at least 3 way to "fix" the issue (that I can think of)

1: a save mechanic for bringing in a Sith Alc Creature (11 or a 16 even)
2: Points for defeating the creature
3: defeating the piece that bring in the Sith Alc also defeats the creatures brought in (sort of like force spirits)

lazy? really? I'm not lazy...I asked a simple question...and I want a rules answer...and there is a spoiler thread int he general forum...besdies mentioning a...oh whatever...you comment still doesn't address my concern...and no one told me anything of a PT process...

ummm...I fixed my comment above...but thanks for editingout my edited question...

The origin of the thread is a rules question. I suggest copying the post(s) laying out the other points you wish to discuss into a new thread in General. Or just type a new one.

If the only legal targets, via the targetting rules, are Droids, you cannot use Sith Alchemy.