Which one of these squads are better?


# Set Name Faction Cost HP Def Att Dam
-- ----- ------------------------------------ ------------ ---- --- --- --- ---
20 ClWar Yoda on Kybuck Republic 51 160 20 14 20
4 ClWar Anakin Skywalker on STAP Republic 35 80 17 7 20
22 KOTOR Captain Panaka Republic 23 70 16 8 10
17 RotS R2-D2, Astromech Droid Republic 9 30 17 8 0
34 CotF Republic Commando - Fixer Republic 16 30 17 9 20
35 CotF Republic Commando - Fixer Republic 16 30 17 9 20
30 CotF Mas Amedda Republic 8 30 14 3 10
12 CS General Kenobi Republic 36 100 19 14 20
59 CotF Ugnaught Demolitionist Fringe 3 10 12 0 10
59 CotF Ugnaught Demolitionist Fringe 3 10 12 0 10


Squad Commander Effects

Captain Panaka
At the end of this character's turn, 2 Medium allies within 6 squares of this character can switch positions.
General Kenobi
Followers can move 2 extra squares on their turns as part of their move.



-----------OR-----------



# Set Name Faction Cost HP Def Att Dam
-- ----- ------------------------------------ ------------ ---- --- --- --- ---
20 ClWar Yoda on Kybuck Republic 51 160 20 14 20
4 ClWar Anakin Skywalker on STAP Republic 35 80 17 7 20
22 KOTOR Captain Panaka Republic 23 70 16 8 10
17 RotS R2-D2, Astromech Droid Republic 9 30 17 8 0
34 CotF Republic Commando - Fixer Republic 16 30 17 9 20
34 CotF Republic Commando - Fixer Republic 16 30 17 9 20
30 CotF Mas Amedda Republic 8 30 14 3 10
7 Kit Fisto, Jedi Master Republic 42 130 20 13 20


Squad Commander Effects

Captain Panaka
At the end of this character's turn, 2 Medium allies within 6 squares of this character can switch positions.

I've also thrown around the idea of swapping out the two Fixers for Dash and an Uggie (in either squad)

Any suggestions?

Basically its a swap squad with YOK and Ani on Stap will get out quick and do some damage before Kit (or GenKen) can get there and beat them down. I like General Kenobi's CE giving the extra two spaces but he's not the beatstick I'd want to swap in. There's a lot I can do with this squad. Like I said, really considering swapping the Fixers for Dash and an Ugg and that'd give me a much better range shooter in Dash than the two Fixers. I'd loose one door gimmick, but the Ugg would replace that a bit (not as tough as the Fixer's door gimmick).

Any suggestions?



Basically, I'm building a squad around these figs:

20 ClWar Yoda on Kybuck Republic 51 160 20 14 20
4 ClWar Anakin Skywalker on STAP Republic 35 80 17 7 20
22 KOTOR Captain Panaka Republic 23 70 16 8 10
17 RotS R2-D2, Astromech Droid Republic 9 30 17 8 0
30 CotF Mas Amedda Republic 8 30 14 3 10

That is a total of 126 points. What are some good swaps for a 200 point squad. Like I said

option A (gain 2 spaces movement, less of a beat stick, most possible door control)
General Kenobi
2 Fixers
2 uggs

Option B: (Gain 2 spaces movement, less beat stick, better dmg from Dash than Fixers)
General kenobi
Dash
3 Uggs

Option C: (best damage possibility, fewest door controllers)
Kit Fisto
Dash
1 Ugg

Option D: (good damage, good door control with fixers, less damage from mids)
Kit Fisto
2 Fixers
0 Uggs


Which of those options seem best?

Think about Plo Koon as a swap option. For 40 pts he has opportunist and LS precision.

I don't think General Kenobi adds enough to justify his points - you already have R2-D2 and Panaka helping Yobuck with movement, and you don't have any swap fodder. So you'll end up getting out-activated and then Windu or Yobuck will be left exposed and will end up getting shot to pieces. I think the Windu/Yobuck combination could work as both have potential to easily take out smaller pieces, but it would be good to have more activations, and pieces like Rodian Brutes and Rodian Diplomats to swap with.