I was thinking something like this would work too; Then you have to choose either Pellaeon OR Opportunist OR Needa's rerolls OR act control OR Super Stealth OR Snowtroop Commander etc...

That might be a bit drastic, though (unless it was a 2 or 3 limit or whatever instead of just 1), because her squares rely on so many of these elements at once, usually.

Once per round, after initiative is determined, you may remove one allied Imperial commander to grant all Imperial trooper allies Charging Fire for the rest of the round.

because how do people counter it? vehicles have a hard time due to their higher life, stealth, evade, can be super stealthed, can charge from across the map with dilpomats and stealth they may not even have legal targets. I know all of this is possible with other pieces, but not at the level this is, high attack values, decent damage, great survivability, great door control, high acts, great speed, etc. you lost to one squad and one squad only. and you beat it once. not even sure how you lost to the mando squad to be honest. I just give Weeks A TON of credit for being a great player because I am still scratching my head about your loss.


Edit* by the looks of this poll she is still a massive npe for the majority of the community. like I said it is overwhelmingly pro change, and BAN still has the highest amount of votes. I am still holding my breathe that this will even out but it appears that change is what the community wants on a much higher scale then staying the way she is.

Of the three main squad types:
- Elite Scout Troopers - are fine, good strong squad, but not OP IMO.
- Dr Daman's Raxus - noone else has managed to do anything with Raxus, so I think it's more of a reflection that he's a very good player who's well practiced with his squad. If I do have a concern in his setup, it's maybe Needa, who is a lot on top of the other attack boosts his squad gets, and means that he basically never misses against moderate defense targets.
- Snowtroopers - I am a little concerned about Snowtroopers still - I know they didn't make the top 4 at GenCon, but after running them at the NZ National tournament I felt like I had masses of power at my disposal and there wasn't much that most of the other squads I played could do against mine - all my wins were fairly comfortable, and three of my five wins were big pastings that were demoralising for my opponent. I would support a change in the Snowtrooper Officer's Rapport from 2 to 1. Snowtroopers are a very one dimensional squad in some ways, and they're probably less likely to win tournaments than the other builds, since they have less tricks. But at the same time, they're very extreme, and make life very un-fun for some squads.

Both of these changes are relatively minor though, and it might not be worth the administrative/confusion effort of a change on top of the previous change to enforce them.

A commander limit completely nerfs every daala build. Why not make it so her CE only works on 10 points or more characters. It would make sence with her inability to lead.

I lose hard to Durge, luke and leia, naboo death shots, snow troops, nomb bombs weeks mandos if they play average and I don't play well.(I have to play well to win any of these. Also mace gowk is rough and so is skybuck. How mandos won was I over extended instead of just staying in gambit on Rhen Var. I made so many play mistakes, from moving the dips to where he could shoot them to moving my scouts within disruptive so they lost super stealth.

Weeks capitalized on all of my mistakes and he himself only made maybe 1 the whole game. Props to weeks he did what no one else could do, but no one has ever beaten me playing this squad the first time.(also his squad is deceptively powerful) The fact is this squad has really rough matchups, but many tricks to counter them if it is your first time playing it. If Lou had played more with naboo that's a rough matchup regardless.

If I had played Tim's luke and leia on speeder I try to have a good time while he kicks my butt. I have plenty of bad matchups, in fact I played most of them, but when it's anyone's first time playing this squad I have the advantage.(unless it is high act Durge or Luke and leia... That rails me)

this this this