LOL you must have been working on that at the same time as me, cuz I just posted that list! Thanks for the Help Robobob!

LOL. I was going through all the Vaders and my head was spinning so I started writing them down. Then I figured I'd share.

Anakin Skywalker, Destroyer of Jedi is very cool and all abilities fit this character very well. Love the LST2 overwhelming force combo! Having no Custom SA's make him easier to judge. 9
Darth Vader, Young Apprentice is definitely undercosted with triple GMA, Sith Rage, ect (especially with Rapport!) compare him with Jaina Sword of the Jedi. Not sure if MotF2 is needed on this character. I f this guy was costed higher my rating would be higher also. 7
Darth Vader, Heartless Killer the name keeps making my think I'm gonna see a Keyblade SA . I definitely see where you were going with this version and could see how useful he would be in a skirmish. However I don't think his force powers would be that weak IMO its hard to judge his cost with those good stats plus Greater Rolling Cleave but no defensive abilities. He makes for an interesting piece nonetheless 8
Darth Vader, Jedi Temple Destroyer has ALOT of different stuff going on, his lower attack is balanced with Momentum and JH. Willing to Serve fit Vader well, however Cleave and Jedi Killer is slightly to much IMO (but better then the rolling cleave he used to have) and I personally don't care for Shockwave. Everything else fits him though. 7
Darth Vader of Mustafar feals like a good old school mini that the should have made in RotS. Everything fits him and make him work just like Vader on Mustafar except for maybe Stable Footing. (If memory serves the terrain did slow him down) he needs to have a slightly higher cost for him standing alone and even higher because of the tech that will boost him up (Bandon, Holosid, ect) Maybe consider changing his name also. 8
Anakin Skywalker, Fallen Hero is definitely my favorite pre-suit Sith Vader. Everything fits him well, and makes him a very deadly force (no pun intended) 10
Darth Vader, the Darkside Unleashed. We cannot vote for or rate our own character in this contest.
Thats all for the pre-suit Vader's I will finish Rating the rest and will place my vote tonight after work. cheers and may the force be with you!

Darth Vader, The Darkside Unleashed (Deathwielded) - He is a powerful beat stick, figure is well put toghether and easily balanced by the cost though. 8
Darth Vader, Lord of Vjun (Robobob) - Everything CorranHorn said I agree with as well as the rating. 9
Darth Vader, Purge of the Jedi (DB35) - A nice spin on a character the cost needs some tweaking though. 7.5
Darth Vader, Heartless Killer (Flying Arrow) - This figure is good and I like how all the abilities go nicely with each other 8
Darth Vader, Brutal Warrior (saber1) - Good piece not much else for me to say. 8
Darth Vader, Champion of the Darkside – AndyHatton - I love this peice the custom abilities are awesome and well suited to him and even with somewhat limited damage output he gets a 9 from me.
Darth Vader, Young Apprentice – SignerJ - This peice does not need that rapport and IMO I think that it undercosts the figure. 6
Darth Vader, Sith Warior - Cassus Fett - Don't Rate My Own Peice
Darth Vader, Jedi Temple Destroyer – CorranHornSux123 - The abilities synergize but balancing is pretty dicey but I like him so. 7
Darth Vader, Instiller of Terror – DieandbeMetal - Honestly Very Generic. 7
Anakin Skywalker, Destroyer of the Jedi – surf_rider56- Bringing 501st Into sith is inventive and Leads to some very interesting possiblities, however like the above entry he is fairly Generic. 8
Darth Vader of Mustafar – Bubba Fett - Not to sure about this guy all i'll say is could have been better. 7
Anakin Skywalker, Fallen Hero - pegolego - Ah Pego, pego, pego I can't decide on how I feel about this peice so I'll go neutral, It's good but flawed (like pretty much ever Mini so thats not saying much) but it's still good. 9 ;..;
Darth Vader Jedi Nightmare- Corran Horn- I love it, love everything about it and you get my vote for winner. 10

^ Reason I missed it was I stole your list order and re edited it to my ratings and thoughs and since you didn't include your self I missed you. Thank you so mich for catching it because I love your peice and I'm voting for you for best peice.

Alright, here goes:

Anakin Skywalker, Destroyer of Jedi (surf_rider56) 9
For surf to not have liked the idea of Sith Vader at first, and put this together quickly, it's one of my favorite Vader's in the contest (naturally, as it has some similarities to mine ). Seems well balanced, being a Commander helps with the balance (especially after he cleaned up that little oversight lol), which, thinking of that, may make mine a tad overcost...

Darth Vader, Yount Apprentice (SignerJ) 7
Not bad. Another that shares a lot of my views on a good Sith Anakin. Seems undercost though, with the ability throw out 90 damage on the move with ease, and you can throw in Holosid for a point basically.

Anakin Skywalker, Fallen Hero (pegolego) Waitaminiute! I can't vote on this!

Darth Vader of Mustafar (Bubba Fett) 10
Love this Vader! I may have gave him 1 less starting FP, and he is a tad undercost I think (you may notice, I almost never complain about overcost, so that may just be me), but those are small gripes. Like the Affinity, and love the concept of a Savage Anakin (plus, Imp. Savage. helps balance him). Well done

Darth Vader, Instiller of Terror (DieAndBeMetal) 7
A cool Vader, though I'm not sure how a couple of the abilities fit post-Mustafar Vader. Seems almost comparable to Lord Vader, but better, a follower, and a bit cheaper (1 point). Very high attack potential, and several good tricks for defense and survivability, and I feel that the Imperial Affinity (it has the Logo, so I assume it's supposed to be there) kinda almost defeats the purpose of a Sith Vader. But, an interesting build of Vader nonetheless.

Darth Vader, Jedi Nightmare (corranhorn) 9
Pretty sweet, low-end Vader. (sort of) a poor-man's Vader, but it can pack a punch! Force Crush is a very fun ability. Again, a possible issure with Holosid and such high starting FP on a Vader, but again, miniscule issue. I like the Cyborg take on Vader, and altogether he's a very nice build.

Darth Vader, Champion of the Dark Side (AndyHatton) 8
Force Choke is cool, and Glove of Darth Vader is fun (though I'm not sure about the second part of it; would understand it if I read the book most likely). It'll have no problem surviving SEVERAL turns with all it's Defense, and has quite an arsenal (albeit, less range of options than on defense) attacking too. The afore-mentioned second half of GoDV possibly makes this a bit over-powered.

Darth Vader, Sith Warrior (Cassus Fett) 8
This one's kind of hard... I LOVE all the abilities, but 170 HP + Armor + LSD +high stats = LONG life. Couple that with a potentially unblock able 120 damage (more with Bandon), potentially higher with Vicious, even with speed 4, I think is a bit much.

Darth Vader, Jedi Temple Destroyer (corranhornsux123) 8
An interesting Vader. Not sure a lot of the abilities will behave together, and he has lower stats than usual. Not much defense either. Not a huge fan of Jedi Killer, with Cleave. Willing to Serve and Pilot help with his balance.

Darth Vader, Brutal Warrior (saber1) 9
A cool Vader, though it has a lot going on (not much more than any of the others though). He seems well balanced, though Brutal Strike and Crushing Blow are dangerous, and the CE giving Momentum, coupled with things like Bandon/Holosid could be some dangerous troops).

Darth Vader, Heartless Killer (FlyingArrow) 8
He may be undercost, but that helps with Bully (which can easily just about any Grunts, and most pieces cheaper than him). That coupled with GMC (not a huge fan of it by itself anyway) can be QUITE crazy, but only in certain situations. FA did well with only a few abilities used (compared to all the other Vader's in this contest).

Darth Vader, Purge of the Jedi (DarthBane53) 8
I don't care too much for Holding Vader's Leash, though it's creative. Final Shot is dangerous, and may not fit being Melee, but it's critical considering he has no extra attacks, and has no way of getting them except Rolling Cleave. Overall not worth the cost, but DB did a pretty good job with the unorthodox route he took on this Vader, so I commend him for that.

Darth Vader, Lord of Vjun (Robobob) 9
RB did a great job on Juyo I think. I like Grasp, Sith Armor/Meditation are nice. I'm not sure about the CE, but he seems like a balanced Vader, though he has potent FP's (Twin Riposte, Rage, Twin Sweep, and again the Grasp).

And, finally, Darth Vader, The Darkside Unleashed (Deathwielded) 10
A well balanced Vader, Fuel of the Darkside is gold. Force Speed can be POWERFUL, but he is a balanced Vader because of some of the OTHER SA choices, which is part of the reason this is so great (Dw resisted the temptation to use Jedi Hunter, and it is more balanced because of it, along with other things like Sith Lightning, though it may not be used usually with Double/GMA). Overall, I love it. A very tame mid-high cost Vader, that can become a MONSTER in an instant if you don't watch out, and well balanced as well.

Overall my vote goes to... (drumroll )... IDK... Bubba's Vader of Mustafar or The Darkside Unleashed by Dw...

Ok, my final vote goes to DARTH VADER, THE DARKSIDE UNLEASHED! . Well done Deathwielded, and a chalice to you as well my friend! . A FULL one too!

From surf_rider56 - Anakin Skywalker, Destroyer of Jedi – Cost 64 balanced (offense+defense) beatstick w/CE. Anakin with unavoidable 80dmg from 6 away versus Jedi with LST2. With Bandon and Revan, can swap right into place adjacent to an enemy and deal unavoidable 150 dmg versus Jedi. Parry/LSD/MotF2 for defense. Plus a good 501st CE. Seems a bit overpowered, even at cost 64. 7.

From SignerJ – Darth Vader, Young Apprentice – Cost 53 beatstick w/no defense vs shooters. 120 on the move with GMA/Sith Rage/Bandon. Block/Motf2/DSS for defense. Will go down quickly versus shooters. Rapport 10 with Sidious means he’s effectively cost 43, which is aggressive costing. 7.

from Pegolego - Anakin Skywalker, Fallen Hero – Cost 79 beatstick w/limited defense. Huge offense. 200dmg on the move versus Jedi with LSA/Rage/JH/Bandon. LST1 gives 100dmg on the move range 6 vs Jedi. Limited defense: DSS, Reflect. Good 501st CE. Huge beatstick that seems costed about right at 79. 8.

from Bubba Fett- Darth Vader of Mustafar - Cost 48 pure offensive beatstick with a savage twist. No defensive abilities and only 19 defense. Maxes out at 90dmg on the move: Ambush/SR/Triple (120 w/Bandon). Impulsive savagery would gain access to Celeste but lose access to Bandon. Impulsive Savagery is good representation of Vader’s reaction to Padme. Loner, Force Leap, and Stable Footing is appropriate to Mustafar. Lightsaber Sweep seems out of place on this piece. Very thematic and fun piece. 10.

from DieAndBeMetal - Darth Vader, Instiller of Terror - Cost 70 balanced (offense+defense) beatstick. Massive unavoidable damage output: Triple/JH/Rage = 120dmg (150 w/Bandon). Dark Armor, Deflect and DSSM for defense. No mobility – only one attack on the move. Grip 4 for ranged attacks, and FR2 to make it feasible. 150 unavoidable seems too high. 7.

from Corranhorn - Darth Vader, Jedi Nightmare - Cost 44 beatstick w/no defense vs shooters. Lower cost than most of the others. No MotF, so have to choose between Overhwelming Force or Sith Rage. Results in max of either 120dmg vs Jedi (Dbl/Mighty Swing/Rage/JH/Bandon) or 100 unavoidable vs Jedi. On the move, only one attack for half that, or use Backlash but lose Mighty Swing. Dark Armor/LS Block for defense. No renewal. Force Crush is 30dmg at range 6 plus a wound (Speed 2 until making a save). Very thematic ability. 9.

from AndyHatton- Darth Vader, Champion of the Dark Side - Cost 68 beatstick w/more defense than other designs. Glove of Darth Vader is most interesting part of this one. Very thematic. Less dmg output and more defense than most other big Vaders. Max output on his own: Triple/JH=90dmg standing still. With help from Wyyrlock/Bandon/ExarKun: 150dmg on the move (but that’s a lot of help!). Plus a zero-time Choke (improved burst lightning). 9.

from Cassus fett- Darth Vader, Sith Warrior - Cost 65 170hp tank. Max dmg: Triple/Adv/MightySwing/Bandon=150 unavoidable with Overwhelming Force. On the move, only 50. Grip 20 for range. Speed 4 is thematic for a Vader too cool to run, but is a big hindrance. LSD/Dark Armor for defense, but no MotF. With that speed, absolutely have to run him with Revan or Caedus for a movement breaker. 8.

from CorranHornsux123- Darth Vader, Jedi Temple Destroyer – 59 point low-HP Jedi Killer. First thought is that 19/9 on a cost 59 piece doesn’t match. JH/Momentum gets him to +17atk, though. I like the Jedi Killer ability (similar to my Greater Rolling Cleave, so of course I think it’s thematic for Vader), but mixing it with Cleave is asking for rules questions. I know we can get Cleave/Rolling Cleave on the same piece already, so it’s a question that has already been answered – just seems unnecessarily complicated. With no defensive abilities, I think he is quite overcosted. Max dmg with Bandon: 60 on the move, 100 standing still. Too low for the cost considering lack of defense (although having all the damage in just one or two big shots is something different). If he could clear people out consistently, that would be different but Jedi Killer is too unreliable since it only works on low-HP force users. 7.

from saber1 Darth Vader, Brutal Warrior – 66 cost beatstick. Max dmg: Triple/JH/CrushingBlow/Bandon = 150dmg. Brutal Strike makes it unavoidable. Only one attack for up to 60 on the move (adds in Momentum). DarkArmor/Deflect/DSS for defense. Damage is high enough you probably wouldn’t bother with Bandon. Troopers gain Momentum through CE. 7.

from FlyingArrow- Darth Vader, Heartless Killer – My entry. Based on the scene of killing younglings in the temple.

From Darthbane53- Darth Vader, Purge of the Jedi - 64 cost one-shot beatstick. Max dmg: one attack for 70 dmg with FinalShot/JH/Bandon. That assumes an enemy with only 50hp, though, and they’d not normally soak 20dmg, so it’s usually overkill. Max 50 vs high HP enemy. Not enough for a 64 cost character without defensive abilities. Rolling Cleave and Final Shot work against each other. 7.

From Robobob- Darth Vader, Lord of Vjun – 58 cost commander/movement breaker with good damage output. Very interesting representation, capturing Vader’s meditation. Sith Meditation seems underpowered, though – I can’t see myself using that one. He’s too high of a cost to spend whole turn gaining 10hp/1fp. Max dmg: 80dmg on the move with Rage/Bandon. SithArmor (improved DarkArmor) for defense, but nothing else. Great CE to help his non-unique allies. Comes with a new movement breaker: Sith Grasp. Way overcosted if just a beatstick, but the movement breaker and CE look like they would work well. Would benefit greatly from Illusion. 10.

from Deathwielded - Darth Vader, The Darkside Unleashed – 65 cost monster beatstick. Max dmg on the move: GMA/Dbl/JHatred/Bandon/Rage/ForceSpeed = 200dmg. LSD/MotF2 for defense. No renewal, but gains FP through new power whenever he defeats enemy. Could be force starved without renewal, but I think you’d always get him renewal somehow. Looks like a lot of fun. 8.

My vote goes to Robobob's Lord of Vjun commander/movement breaker, edging out Bubba Fett's savage Vader of Mustafar.

Sith Lightning is to represented from the Revenge of the Sith Video Game, the only time Vader actually used Lightning anyway this is the slim and narrow time frame to give any Vader any kind of Lightning.
And I just didn't get around to giving him a Flavor text
"A great representation of a pre-lava bath Vader." LOL!

Well, thank you . I truly appreciate that. He was one of my favorite customs I've made because of how different he is from all my other pieces.

So far, though I haven't added all the totals, it looks like Bubba Fett has an edge over the competition with his popular 'Mustafar' Vader.

My schedule is a little crazy today, I'm working on my list when I can. At the very least I'll post my favorite and ammend the list later.